Key Components of a Stewardship Plan

Securing a major gift is a milestone. Keeping that donor engaged and feeling deeply connected to the mission is what ensures future giving, advocacy, and long-term partnership. That’s where stewardship comes in—not as an afterthought, but as a strategic, intentional process. A well-structured stewardship plan ensures major donors feel valued, see the impact of their gift, and remain inspired to give again.
Here are the key components every philanthropy officer should include in a stewardship plan for a major gift donor:
1. Donor Profile and Gift Summary
Start by clearly documenting:
- Donor’s name and contact details
- Gift amount, date, and designation
- Type of gift (e.g. one-time, pledge, DAF, in-kind)
- Any specific donor expectations (recognition preferences, reporting requirements)
This creates a foundation for all future stewardship activities.
2. Stewardship Goals
Define what you aim to achieve through stewardship. These goals might include:
- Deepening the donor’s emotional connection to the cause
- Demonstrating transparency and accountability
- Positioning the donor for future support or involvement
- Encouraging donor advocacy or peer influence
Goals should align with your broader donor engagement and retention strategy.
3. Recognition Plan
Determine how the donor will be acknowledged, ensuring it’s appropriate and aligned with their preferences:
- Public recognition: Annual reports, newsletters, website, donor wall
- Private recognition: Handwritten notes, personal calls from leadership
- Naming rights or other formal honours
Some donors seek public visibility; others prefer discretion. Tailor accordingly.
4. Impact Reporting
Major donors want to see their investment at work. Create a plan to report outcomes, such as:
- Narrative updates on the funded program
- Metrics and key performance indicators (KPIs)
- Quotes or stories from beneficiaries
- Photos or videos of the project in action
Reporting should be timely, engaging, and mission-focused—not just administrative.
5. Communication Calendar
Develop a 12–18 month schedule of planned touchpoints, which may include:
- Quarterly or biannual progress updates
- Annual thank-you call or donor briefing
- Invitations to events or site visits
- Special notes on birthdays, holidays, or gift anniversaries
Use a CRM to track and schedule these activities, ensuring consistency and follow-through.
6. Leadership Involvement
Determine when and how organisational leadership should be involved:
- CEO or Board Chair thank-you call
- Personalised message from program staff
- Inclusion in strategic briefings or closed-door donor forums
Major donors appreciate access and insight—leverage leadership thoughtfully.
7. Opportunities for Deeper Engagement
Include steps to foster stronger donor connection, such as:
- Invitations to volunteer or serve on a committee
- Involvement in donor advisory groups or giving circles
- Personalised tours or behind-the-scenes program access
- Speaking opportunities (if the donor is a community leader)
Engagement keeps donors emotionally invested beyond their initial contribution.
8. Planned Future Asks (Soft Positioning)
While stewardship is not solicitation, it’s wise to consider long-term potential:
- Would this donor be open to a multi-year pledge?
- Is there a planned giving discussion on the horizon?
- Are they a prospect for a future capital campaign?
Track indicators and plan soft engagement around future opportunities—without rushing.
9. Documentation and CRM Entry
Log the full stewardship plan and all related activities in your CRM:
- Scheduled actions and follow-up reminders
- Copies of reports sent and events attended
- Notes from conversations or feedback received
This ensures continuity across staff and safeguards the donor relationship.
10. Evaluation and Adjustment
Periodically assess whether the stewardship efforts are effective:
- Has the donor responded positively?
- Are they more engaged or referring others?
- Do they express satisfaction with reporting and recognition?
Be prepared to adjust the plan to better suit the donor’s evolving needs and interests.
Major gift stewardship is not a checkbox activity—it’s a curated, personalised journey that reflects the donor’s impact and your organisation’s integrity. When done well, it leads to stronger relationships, increased giving, and donor advocacy. For philanthropy officers, a strategic stewardship plan is as important as the cultivation and solicitation strategy that came before it.